NOWHERE IN PARTICULAR


Author’s note: I’d like to thank everybody for their support. Your likes and comments are a source of inspiration.

NOWHERE IN PARTICULAR

By

Robert Robinson

Word count: 1,383

I leaned against the tailgate, watching the Sun expose the flatlands below, wondering if I’d miss any of it. I’d breezed through Denver in the wee hours, instinctively not wanting to add to the feted and festering flotsam that collects along the Front Range. I was heading into the mountains; away from humidity and sweat; away from those who lean on the brass bull and are defined by profits and stuff; away from those who would happily sell their mother’s soul for a quart of beer and a twenty-rock—they are “the others,” and I wouldn’t miss them. I wouldn’t miss home either. I’d never had one.

I’d attended fifteen different schools in five states before quitting high school to go into the service, so when people asked me where I was from, I’d answer, “Nowhere in particular.” I’d owned property and lived out of my truck, been married and gotten divorced, played the game and dropped out. The only thing that had been a constant for me through it all had been fly fishing.

It was fly fishing for wild trout as much as a desire to put distance between me and the flatlands that drew me to the Inner Mountain West; the final destination of Hemmingway, and the refuge of Wallace Stegner, Edward Abbey, and Harry Middleton—interminable drifters and seekers who’d found something out here in this bigness that reminds you to be small.

Hemmingway found a shotgun—perhaps his ego wouldn’t compress. Middleton found people living on the fringe of society who cared for him, a beautiful woman, and a blind trout. Stegner and Abbey found purpose in a love of land that sucked them into causes and battles. Stegner fought the damn dam builders and retreated to Vermont to die; Abbey stayed and continued the fight until his death; and Middleton took his memories back to Alabama, county garbage truck no. 2, depression, and a brain hemorrhage. The common denominator then was death, and I wondered if that’s what I would find among these wind scoured peeks. I’d come to catch wild trout in stream gouged canyons and hold God in my hand. I found a land in trouble.

I met people able to strip mountains of their beauty for profit and leave with their hubris intact. I met people who’d lived here all their lives, looking up at the mountains every day, never bothering to go up there. Those that did go left a trail of beer cans, worm containers, and dirty diapers, striding through the land with a total disregard for anything but self. I couldn’t go deep enough into the high country to escape corporate America, illegal gillnet operations, and the glint of empty beer cans. The federal government claimed some of the high ground, creating national forests, parks, and monuments in an effort to preserve as much of the land as they could. But the flatland politicians don’t like that, and they’re making moves to declare that land state land; their corporate buddies will pay big money to develop, drill, dig, and cut their way to greater wealth. The scars of scraping, digging, and over-grazing mark their trails, and blue exhaust hangs in the high-country canyons like fat on a bishop. They are embryonic gods, put here to “prosper on the land,” destined to rule over their own planets and galaxies.

It took a while for my obsession with fly fishing to become more about the places it took me than about catching fish, and it wasn’t until frantic bumbling turned to quiet competence, until manic passion gave way to quiet reflection that I started looking around. The passage of time etched into the khaki sandstone cliffs highlighted my puny life span, leaving me with a profound sense of my nothingness. The power that formed these mountains was hard to comprehend. These sweeping valleys surrounded by snow covered peaks outlined against a hard-blue sky made it impossible for me to think that I mattered, and I doubted if any of society’s petty doings mattered.

I’d come west from the east, where impressive things are built, brick by brick, by people. But no earthmover, no economically enslaved civilization could build these mountains. The cliff faces told of their violent birth, the boulders in the valleys, of their constant change. No, people could not build mountains, but they could destroy them.

The mountains are under assault from corporations, environmentalists, outdoor enthusiasts, and ranchers—Corporations want to mine, log, and use the water for their cooling towers; environmentalists want to restrict access; outdoor enthusiasts want more access; and ranchers need to graze and water crops. And people need jobs.

All sides are convinced of the moral superiority of their respective positions, believing the other side to be either moon bats, incapable of reasonable discourse, or robber barons, bent on the destruction of nature in the name of godless capitalism. There’s some truth to both viewpoints, but neither side will own those inconvenient truths—half-truth is more easily embraced, as whole truth is always messy. There are no all-satisfying solutions to any of this. It’s a cluster.

The biggest fights in the West are over water. There’s a saying out here: “Whiskey’s for drinkin’, water’s for fightin’ over.” It’s possible to be beaten or even murdered over water—it is the Wild West, after all—and everybody has a dog in the fight; old recluse fly fishermen included. The steely-eyed, quietly-moral westerner is a myth; a man’s word means the same thing here as it does anywhere else—absolutely nothing. So instead of honorably tradin’ lead, these battles are mostly fought with money and lawyers; the lawyers being the big winners. The losers?—wildlife, forests, and people. I realized the hopelessness of it all when I attended a function put on by a local conservation group.

I looked around the room and it was obvious these well intentioned geriatric hippies didn’t have the money to fight protracted legal battles, and short of going to the state capitol and setting their ponytails and beards on fire, they were unlikely to garner much attention to their cause. The guy we’d come to hear speak wasn’t Edward Abbey, and as far as ground forces, well, there were no Haydukes in the crowd. The big money concerns are consolidated, the environmentalists divided, and ranchers in the West have never been able to agree on the color of scat. But they aren’t the mountain’s only enemies; natural enemies can be just as destructive, and the forest service’s trial-and-error methods of management—mostly errors—leave the mountains ripe for devastation that takes a generation to recover from.

There’s nothing sadder than hillsides covered in the dead brown and quiet gray of beetle-killed pines. Add drought and you have a forest of powdery tinder primed for storms that bring little rain but plenty of lightning. Fires rage for weeks, leaving burn-scared canyons, ash covered streams and bristling forests of blackened sticks. After a fire, the runoff sends walls of rocks, mud, and debris into the valleys, blowing out roads, choking off creeks, killing fish. They bring in heavy equipment to repair roads and open up streams, creating more problems. Seeing a D-9 Catt sitting in the middle of what was once a blue-ribbon trout fishery, leaking hydraulic fluid and oil is—well.

I’d come to the mountains to fish for wild trout and found refuge and a sense of purpose. I found quixotic battles, passed down by fallen legends, waiting to be fought. And I found indescribable beauty. For the first time in my life I noticed the wonderment around me. I caught myself looking up a lot, watching the wind whip ribbons of ice crystals from snow covered peaks, and when that arctic air washed into the high valleys, I felt a cleansing—down deep. I understood why ancient people held mountains sacred. I would never have figured that out on the hot, muggy flatlands, and I knew I’d done good by coming here. I also knew I could no longer stand on a mountain, looking down, feeling smug. I now had an answer for the question, “Where ya from?” I wasn’t from “nowhere in particular” anymore. And it no longer mattered why I’d come.

© Robert Robinson 2015 Unauthorized use and/or duplication of this material without express and written permission from this blog’s author and/or owner is strictly prohibited. Excerpts and links may be used, provided that full and clear credit is given to Robert Robinson and with appropriate and specific direction to the original content.

24 thoughts on “NOWHERE IN PARTICULAR

  1. It is amazing how, from the point of view of each group’s interest, common sense usually does take a back seat when it comes to what to do (or not do) with natural resources. Enjoyable post. Provokes a few thoughts without the heavy-handedness.

    • Thank you. Common sense doesn’t enter into it, I’m afraid. At times nature turns against herself, and there’s no stopping that. But when I look at the time etched into the mountains, I wonder if we humans really matter in the long run. The mountains will breath a sigh of relief when we’re gone.

  2. “…this bigness that reminds you to be small.” Indeed. As everything in real life is, it is complex, with no easy answers. Your ability to recognize the variety of lenses through which the mountains are seen is rare. My hope is that the mountains will outlive us all. Another great piece, Rob.

  3. So, Rob, I read this piece a couple of times yesterday, and then again this morning, and I’m still hesitant to comment because I don’t think I can find the words to tell you how magnificent this piece is from beginning to end.Certain sentences called forth remembrance, identification, and emotion from me: “…interminable drifters and seekers who’d found something out here in this bigness that reminds you to be small,” I’ve felt that, Rob. “It took a while for my obsession with fly fishing to become more about the places it took me than about catching fish,” My dad explained that to me when I questioned why he hunted deer. “…it was obvious these well intentioned geriatric hippies …,” I’ve been in those meetings. And every sentence you wrote to describe the beauty and grandeur of mountains resounded within me. You captured the mountains, you captured the west, you captured the issues. I think there will be a bidding war over this piece.

    PS The book-loving side of me took particular delight in your descriptions of the gigantic men, important in my reading life, who wrote about and cared about the west. I was not familiar with Middleton, but, thanks to you, have googled him and know about him now. Again, magnificent.

    • I’m humbled by your kind words. I always wonder what you’ll think about these pieces, as you know the country, the people, and our western problems. You simply must read Middleton’s book “The Bright Country.” I was up on the left fork yesterday on a scout with my dog, Touch. We were sitting in a stand of aspen, shading up after hiking up the ridge, looking across at a snowbank and I thought about the twists and turns in my life that lead me to that spot–no one would believe it. I hardly believe it myself. I feel better about this piece now that I have your approval. 🙂

      • I’m glad you found my comment meaningful, Rob. I have Middleton’s “The Bright Country” on my reading list, as well as Stegner’s essays, but I forgot the author of River and I think you told me about a third book and I remember neither title nor author for it. Could you send me the information my brain missed?

      • River was written by Colin Fletcher. David Gessner is the author of All The Wild That Remains, “Edward Abby, Wallace Stegner. and the American West. Colin Fletcher was the first person to hike the complete Grand Canyon. He wrote a book about that titled The Man Who Walked Through Time. I’ll drop you an email, as well.

  4. I love how the hugeness of the great outdoors shines through in this story. It has a touch of sadness that I hope is only fiction, but the picture you painted is vivid. And I love that you are UTAH Rob, not NO WHERE IN PARTICULAR Rob. 🙂

  5. I looooved this piece. There’s so much that I can relate to, although I know that we’re in different parts of the West–fires, beetle infestations, water rights, loud-mouthed activists, power-hungry politicians, incompetency in a time of urgency, etc. Two lines in particular that I thought were pure genius were: “this bigness that reminds you to be small,” and “I’d come to catch wild trout in stream gouged canyons and hold God in my hand.” I’ve felt those feelings, but I’ve never been able to form them into words as perfect as yours. You have such a talent.

    I’ll admit that I don’t hold Abbey in much esteem. I’ve read Desert Solitaire three times (not by my own volition, though), and I still can’t get over his hypocrisy and selfishness. He lauds being alone in the desert when, in reality, he often had his wife and child with him–alone, indeed. He also praises the place, but essentially says, “Don’t come here.” Several times he calls for there to be no roads and no access (aside from hiking) to his beloved desert. How can you ask the masses to care for and protect a place when you simultaneously want to refuse them access to the place? Not my favorite critter.

    • Thanks for such kind words. I’m glad you liked the piece. Those two lines are my favorites as well. It’s nice when people pick up on those special lines.
      Abby was able to motivate others, and that’s probably his only virtue–he certainly was not a moral person–and I don’t think he ever truly felt small in the bigness. You should read “All The Wild That Remains.” My favorite of the three I mentioned is Middleton. He let the mountains heal his mind, and approached them without pretensions. I would never have liked Abby personally though. I’ve never liked guys who thought they were god’s gift. Thanks so much again for the kind words.

  6. Pingback: Catching Up: Blogs that NEED to be Read | At the Foot of the Sierras

  7. So true, and sad….. being in the southeast these past months I am disgusted by the lack of respect for our land and nature…. I have never seen more trashy piled up along the roads as I have here and in alabama… when it raina of course it fills the rivers creeks and lakes with garbage…. Islands of plastic bottles float around… it hurts my heart and I wonder if God is as disgusted as I am at the lack of appreciation for this beautiful land that humans are destroying with thier modern necessities. ….. I really enjoyed this one, it just hurts that this is the truth everywhere you look… and I am like you I see the incredible beauty of a land that is being forsaken….

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s